The Horror Asylum

Sign Up   Forgot password? 

11335 awesome articles | 6863 horror movies | 1416 horror reviews | 202 interesting interviews Established in 2001  
The Horror Asylum
  Latest News   Reviews   Giveaways   Interviews
Movies | TV | DVDs | Books | Games Movies | DVD | Books Just Added | Ending Soon Just Added | Archives
Home | Enquiries/Submissions | Advertise | Feeds | Cookies | About | Dark Lounge

Latest Horror Headlines
Shriekfest 2014 Preview: 'Hungerford' Review The Influence of Oddity - 'American Horror Story: Freak Show' Sam Haynes' Haunt of Horror Offers up 'Spine Chillers' this Halloween 'Game of Thrones' Stars Join 'Pride and Prejudice and Zombies'
A Two-Faced 'American Horror Story: Freak Show' Clip Empire Reveal a Number of New 'Interstellar' Stills The Sexy Natalie Dormer Signs up for 'Patient Zero' Universal Release Latest 'Ouija' Trailer

Reaper DVD Giveaway
Reaper DVD Giveaway
Houdini DVD Giveaway
Houdini DVD Giveaway
Afflicted DVD Giveaway
Afflicted DVD Giveaway
Leprechaun: Origins DVD Giveaway
Leprechaun: Origins DVD Giveaway
WIN Brain Food Popcorn Bowl from NOW TV
WIN Brain Food Popcorn Bowl from NOW TV
The Walking Dead: The Complete Fourth Season Giveaway
The Walking Dead: The Complete Fourth Season Giveaway


The Phantom of the Opera
Buy from Play.com Buy from Zavvi.com

The Phantom of the Opera (1989)

movie | Movie Details
Images, Posters, News
| Comments
Have your say

Plot Summary:

"In this version of the Gaston Leroux classic, Erik is not the vicim of an accident but a man who sells his soul for supernatural powers."


Review by
Ryan McDonald
Follow me:
@horrorasylum
Review Date: 21 June 2010 My Rating: out of 5

 
 

Music student Jill Schoelen is knocked silly at an audition whilst singing something from 19th Century British composer Erik Destler. She wakes up in 19th Century London as an understudy in Faust in an opera house supposedly haunted by a Phantom. The Phantom of course is Destler (Robert Englund, AKA Freddy Krueger) who long ago sold his soul to the Devil at the cost of his once handsome face now radically and freakishly scarred. Destler becomes obsessed with Schoelen, giving her private tuition lessons whilst still hiding his horrific visage. But thatís not all heís hiding...heís a violent and volatile murderer, whilst inspector Terence Harvey (quite good) is on his trail.

Some will be put-off by the very idea of it, but this Dwight H. Little version of the Gaston Leroux classic attempts a slasher movie bent on the oft filmed tale. For what it is, it works rather well, and itís always nice to see the underrated Schoelen on-screen, something we donít get anymore. Sheís always been a lovely, sweet, and wholly unappreciated screen presence, and this film is no exception.

I like the idea of downplaying the Phantomís romantic side and upping his sinister side. Not only is it a nice counter to the Andrew Lloyd Webber vision, but it allows horror actor Englund to feel more comfortable in the role. Englundís more than just Freddy (though rarely allowed to show us anything else), but heís no Casanova letís face it. Englund, whilst classically trained, is no Olivier, but heís perfectly fine for this interpretation of the role. Itís not a Freddy film, though. Thereís one or two moments that are deliberately Freddy-esque, but otherwise this is just a slasher film version of 'Phantom of the Opera'. This sledge-hammer driven film wonít win any awards for subtlety, but it works (I love the idea of the Phantom making masks out of sewn human skin, God help me!), and itís directed and shot with quite a bit of style. Iím shocked at how lavish it is for a film by such a normally nondescript filmmaker.

Purists to the tale wonít get this at all and will be offended by the gore, let alone the lack of the chandelier scene! God forbid! Well, thatís their problem. For me, the mixture of gore and high art was actually sickly amusing, and presumably intentionally so. The makeup is by Kevin Yagher with some additional help from a team supervised by John Carl Buechler. Itís actually really terrific, and only occasionally Freddy-like in visual design, and when it does, itís a little annoying.

I do have one big problem with the film, though. Actually, two, if you include the scary revelation that this is a Menahem Golan (he being the co-founder of Cannon Films, the schlockiest production company of the 80s and home to every Chuck Norris and Michael Dudikoff film you can name) production. I kid, I kid, I jest, though this is surely one of the most lavish films Golan has ever been involved with (this oneís from his 21st Century Film Corporation, though, in association with Harry Alan Towers). No, what really prevents this from being anything truly memorable is the lack of scenes shared by Englund and Schoelen in the first 45 minutes, so that their connection never feels authentic as the film moves to its climax. Englundís Phantom spends far too long in the shadows, watching Schoelen from afar. I also found the modern day wraparound to be unnecessary and rather silly, but thatís a minor quibble.

OVERALL SUMMARY
Is this the best version of the tale? God no, but it has its merits and it has its place. I kinda liked it. If nothing else, itís better than Dario Argentoís disastrous version (thereís no rat fetish in this one), though Joel Schumacherís screen rendering of the ALW musical is probably the best of the lot, cinematically.




Blood and Guts: Comments

Username:
Password:

Not Registered?
Sign up for FREE >>




VOTE ON THIS

Rated 2.9/5 stars (67 votes cast)

 
There are currently no comments.
Why not have your say!?



HORROR REVIEWS


Prank (Short) Movie Review

Prank (Short)




Skypemare (Short) Movie Review

Skypemare (Short)




Alice D Movie Review

Alice D




Life After Beth Movie Review

Life After Beth




Hungerford Movie Review

Hungerford




Time Lapse Movie Review

Time Lapse



Funny Nerdy Shirts
Funny Nerdy Shirts

INTERVIEWS


An Interview with Marta Milans
An Interview with Marta Milans



An Interview with Jemma Dallender
An Interview with Jemma Dallender



An Interview with Eli Roth and the Cast of Hemlock Grove
An Interview with Eli Roth and the Cast of Hemlock Grove



An Interview with Stephen Mera
An Interview with Stephen Mera



An Interview with David Jung
An Interview with David Jung



An Interview with Bobcat Goldthwait
An Interview with Bobcat Goldthwait



An Interview with Jason Blum
An Interview with Jason Blum



An Interview with Kaare Andrews
An Interview with Kaare Andrews



An Interview with Lou Simon
An Interview with Lou Simon


Original Horror Shirts

LATEST GIVEAWAYS


Houdini DVD Giveaway
Houdini DVD Giveaway



Reaper DVD Giveaway
Reaper DVD Giveaway



Leprechaun: Origins DVD Giveaway
Leprechaun: Origins DVD Giveaway



WIN Brain Food Popcorn Bowl from NOW TV
WIN Brain Food Popcorn Bowl from NOW TV



Afflicted DVD Giveaway
Afflicted DVD Giveaway



Earthworks Kickstarter iPad Air Giveaway
Earthworks Kickstarter iPad Air Giveaway



The Walking Dead: The Complete Fourth Season Giveaway
The Walking Dead: The Complete Fourth Season Giveaway



From Dusk Till Dawn: Season One Giveaway
From Dusk Till Dawn: Season One Giveaway



Win Hannibal The Complete Season 2 on DVD
Win Hannibal The Complete Season 2 on DVD



Night of the Comet Dual Format Giveaway
Night of the Comet Dual Format Giveaway



Twitter
Vampires.com Werewolves.com
Facebook




Funny Shirts